Thanksgiving at 2 p.m.: Is That Dinner, or Just a Very Large Lunch?

Public · Open
1

This is your only flag for 48 hours. One hundred flags on this same poll blur it and block its author for 60 days when the flags are at least 70% higher than the likes.

You should not flag this poll simply because you disagree with it. Use the comments to share your disagreement.

When the turkey comes out around 2 in the afternoon, is that Thanksgiving dinner, or is it lunch with a fancier name? And if everyone eats again after the game, which sitting was the real meal?

Every family has a clock for Thanksgiving, and almost nobody agrees on what that clock means. In my house the bird comes out of the oven in the early afternoon, usually somewhere around 2, because that is when the people driving in can sit down together before someone has to leave. The table is set. The good plates are out. Someone says dinner is ready. And every year the same argument starts before the first roll is passed. If the sun is still up, is this dinner, or did we just move lunch to a bigger table and give it a holiday name? I grew up thinking dinner was the meal you eat when the day is over. A 2 o'clock plate, no matter how much turkey is on it, still feels like lunch to me. The counterargument in the kitchen is simple. Thanksgiving decides the name, not the hour. You do not call the biggest meal of the year lunch just because a football game is still in the first quarter. The people who drove three hours did not come for a late lunch. They came for dinner, and dinner is whenever the cook says it is. I have stood in that kitchen holding a serving spoon, losing the argument, and still not convinced. A meal can be enormous and still be lunch. Then there is the second sitting. Plenty of houses eat at 2 and eat again at 8, sandwiches over the sink, pie on the couch, somebody calling that one the real dinner. Pie is the tell. If dessert shows up before the late game, somebody at the table is treating the afternoon as the main event. If the pies stay covered until night, the first plate was only the opening act. So which plate counts? The one with the speeches and the good plates, or the one after dark when the house finally gets quiet? I want to know what your table does. If you sit down while it is still light out, say what you call that meal, and if you eat twice, say which one you would miss if you had to pick.

Sign in to vote.

Results

0 Responses
0 0%
2 p.m. is dinner.
0 0%
2 p.m. is lunch.
0 0%
We eat twice. Night is the real one.
0 0%
We eat twice. Afternoon is the real one.

Comments

Comments open after you vote. They stay hidden until then, and they never show how anyone answered.