An Alien's Guide to American Politics: Are Both Sides Part of the Problem?

Public · Open
1

This is your only flag for 48 hours. One hundred flags on this same poll blur it and block its author for 60 days when the flags are at least 70% higher than the likes.

You should not flag this poll simply because you disagree with it. Use the comments to share your disagreement.

After hearing both sides explain their political beliefs, the alien has one question: If Democrats and Republicans both claim to represent the people but continually try to defeat opposing viewpoints, are both contributing to the problem?

An ordinary Earthling has been given the unusual opportunity to explain American politics to an advanced alien civilization. These aliens have mastered science, technology, and logical reasoning. They have a habit of breaking complicated situations down to their simplest terms. The Earthling explains that the United States has two major political parties: Democrats and Republicans. Democrats generally believe government should actively help people and create a more level playing field. They worry that without government oversight, wealthy individuals and powerful corporations can take advantage of workers, concentrate wealth, and widen the gap between rich and poor. They support spending on healthcare assistance, public education, affordable housing, food assistance, worker protections, and social services. Republicans generally emphasize individual responsibility, personal freedom, self-reliance, and limited government. They worry that excessive government intervention, taxation, and regulation restrict economic opportunity, discourage businesses from growing, and create dependency. They favor lower taxes, fewer regulations, strong national defense, border security, and policies they believe encourage investment and economic growth. The alien listens carefully. "So one group believes government must protect ordinary people from the powerful, while the other believes too much government power can restrict individual freedom and opportunity?" The Earthling agrees. The alien asks how the two groups decide which ideas to implement. The Earthling explains that both compete for elections and political control. They frequently oppose the other party's proposals, sometimes even when compromise might be possible. The alien pauses. "Let me understand. Both groups claim they want to improve society. Both want to spend taxpayer money on their priorities. Both believe their approach is better. And both frequently try to discredit, obstruct, or defeat the opposing side." After considering this, the alien asks: "If both sides are so convinced they are right that they would rather crush opposing viewpoints than work together toward solutions, doesn't that make both sides part of the problem? "Perhaps the question isn't which side is evil. Perhaps it's why your political system rewards people for fighting each other instead of working together." The Earthling has no immediate answer.

Sign in to vote.

Results

0 Responses
0 0%
Both parties are equally part of the problem
0 0%
One party is more responsible than the other
0 0%
Neither party is the problem; the political system is
0 0%
Both parties have legitimate differences and should stand their ground
0 0%
Compromise should matter more than party loyalty
0 0%
I don't know / Need more information

Comments

Comments open after you vote. They stay hidden until then, and they never show how anyone answered.