Christmas Music Before Thanksgiving: Where Do You Draw the Line?
Christmas music is already playing in some stores and cars during the second week of November. When should it start: before Thanksgiving, the day after, the first of December, or the week of Christmas?
By the second week of November, Christmas music is already playing in some stores, on some radio stations, and in some cars. Other places are still on fall playlists and will not switch until the dishes from Thanksgiving are put away. The disagreement is about the calendar, not about the songs themselves. One side hears the first carol as the start of a season they look forward to all year. Lights go up, plans get made, and the music is what makes a dark evening feel like the holidays have room to breathe. They point out that the songs are finite, the season is short, and waiting until late December leaves only a few days to enjoy them. For them, hearing the music in November is no different from seeing pumpkins in September. The calendar in the store and the calendar on the wall have never matched, and they do not need them to. The other side hears the same song as a rush. Thanksgiving still has its own table, its own week, and its own traditions, and a carol in the aisle can make that holiday feel like a stop on the way to the next one. They would rather keep November for what is already on the calendar and let Christmas music begin when Thanksgiving is actually over, or even later, when December has started. For them, a season is easier to enjoy when it is not asked to share the month. They can like the songs and still want a few quiet weeks before the playlist changes. Neither habit is new. Some households have started the playlist the day after Halloween for as long as anyone can remember. Others treat the Friday after Thanksgiving as a fixed line, and some wait until December. The question is where the line falls this year. If a carol comes on before the turkey, when do you count the season as started?